Homicide, not suicide? Clues that led Michael Freeman to suspect foul play in Epstein’s death

Forensic expert Michael Freeman believes Jeffrey Epstein was killed in his jail cell in 2019. His case for homicide turns on a second mark on Epstein’s neck that ran in a different direction from the first.
Warning: This article contains details and references to suicide, which some readers may find distressing.
Epstein was awaiting trial on federal sex trafficking charges when he was found dead at Manhattan’s Metropolitan Correctional Center on 10 August 2019. New York City’s medical examiner ruled the death a suicide by hanging and stands by that finding.
Now, Dr Freeman, who served as a cause-of-death expert in high-profile cases, including that of George Floyd in Minnesota, claims there are clues indicating the financier was assaulted in his prison cell.
Freeman presented his independent analysis in London on 16 November, saying that he reviewed autopsy records and photographs supplied by Epstein’s brother, Mark, and built a 3D model to test whether the position in which the notorious financier was reportedly found could account for his injuries.
Up close: Epstein’s brother claims new report will allege financier was murdered
What signs led Freeman to suspect homicide?
Speaking to the BBC, Freeman insisted that his analysis was independent and had nothing to do with Mark Epstein. He pointed to the body’s condition during the autopsy and several inconsistencies in the post-mortem report.
- Two neck marks running in different directions. One angled upwards, as Freeman would expect in a hang. The second sat lower and ran more horizontally. He argued that even two loops tied to the same point would both pull upwards. The lower mark, he said, fit the angle of a cloth strip pulled from behind.
- The fractures made two attempts unlikely in his view. Freeman doubted Epstein could have fractured his hyoid bone and thyroid cartilage on a first attempt and stayed conscious enough to try again.
- A knot could explain the scrape at the back of the neck. Freeman pointed to a narrow orange loop with two knots in a photograph of the cell. He thought the uneven marks at the front poorly matched the noose investigators recovered. Investigators did not collect the loop he singled out for examination.
- Possible fingernail scratches above the neck mark. Freeman thought Epstein might have left the scratches while trying to pull the cloth away.
- Bleeding deep in the left shoulder. Freeman interpreted the bleeding in the muscle as evidence of a blow. He also pointed to facial injuries he associated with blows and an injury on the back. He said the hanging scenario he modelled did not explain those injuries.
Freeman’s theory is that someone strangled Epstein from behind and probably used the same strip of cloth to suspend his body from the bunk.
The autopsy examiner found the fractures and the upward neck mark consistent with hanging. She said there were no defensive injuries to Epstein’s hands, such as broken fingernails or bruised knuckles. The official ruling still stands as suicide by hanging.
Read more: Hidden Jeffrey Epstein suicide note published by US court
The reconstruction, however, had a gap, as no photograph showed Epstein’s body before it was taken down. Freeman relied in part on an account a prison guard who found Epstein gave investigators two years later, and his research is yet to be peer-reviewed.