Is your business ready for investors? Check these three numbers first

What to work out before you raise money, and how risk shapes the return investors expect
Founder of the international accelerator and IT platform for business management Business Booster, venture investor, and specialist in mergers and acquisitions of companies.
Photo: Pexels

Investors want answers to two questions. How much could I make, and what could go wrong? Everything else, from the founders’ track record to the team and the product, helps them judge the risk. Those two questions explain how much of a stake an investor might ask for and which businesses are finding it easier to raise money today.

Should you borrow or sell a stake?

If you need money to expand production or cover day-to-day costs, you have two options. You can borrow at an agreed rate of interest, or you can bring in an equity investor.

  • A loan has to be repaid with interest. You keep full ownership of the business.
  • An equity investment brings in a substantial sum to fund a project or a growth plan. In exchange, the investor takes a stake and becomes a co-owner.

As an investor, I often take a two-step approach. I might lend a business $100,000 at 15–20% a year to help a project get started. If it goes well, we can talk about my taking a stake. That gives me a chance to see how the business works before making a bigger commitment.

Three numbers to work out

Before you can decide how much equity to offer, you need three figures.

  1. What the company is worth today.
  2. How much its value could increase after the investment.
  3. The return an investor would need to make the deal worthwhile.

When there’s no collateral or guarantee, the investor has to consider what happens if the owner can no longer work, the business closes, or political upheaval or some other unforeseen event disrupts operations. Here’s how I think about annual returns at different levels of risk.

Where the money goesAnnual return
A bank deposit covered by a government guaranteeAbout 5%
A high-risk projectAbout 25%
A small private company with few safeguards for investors35–50%

Put yourself in the investor’s shoes before proposing terms. Does the potential payoff justify the risk they’d be taking?

Would you come out ahead?

Suppose I own 100% of a company that makes about $500,000 a year. I raise $300,000–$400,000, and the business goes on to make $1 million a year. If I provide the investor a 20% stake and we split the profits accordingly, my share comes to $800,000. That’s $300,000 more than I was making as the sole owner.

That’s the test I use. If my income rises after the deal, bringing in an investor or partner makes sense to me.

What investors look at

Investors use what they learn about the founder, team and product to judge the business’s chances of success.

  • The founder. I see relatively little risk in backing someone on their fifth venture whose first two businesses failed and whose next two succeeded.
  • The team. Do people already know how to do the job, or will they need training from scratch?
  • The product. It could fall flat or find only a modest market.

The decision depends on whether the expected return is high enough to justify those risks.

Start-ups and established businesses

Venture capital funds seek companies with the potential to grow a hundredfold because only a few of the start-ups they back will really take off. In a portfolio of equally sized bets, a hundredfold return on just 1% of those investments would roughly cover the original outlay. To turn a profit, a fund needs more big winners. That could mean 5%, 10% or even 15% of the portfolio taking off. Nobody can reliably predict how many will.

Established businesses generally carry far less risk. They can make a worthwhile investment with much more modest growth.

‘There’s nobody else in this market. We’ll take it by storm.’ That pitch can win over someone who made their money running a conventional business and is new to venture investing. A seasoned investor hears the same pitch and sees a big risk. They’ll need the prospect of an exceptional return before they commit.

Where investors are looking now

  1. Everyday businesses have a better shot than many owners think. Car washes, garages, cafés, restaurants and clinics can all attract investment because they tend to carry less risk.
  2. Steady cash flow has become more attractive. Early-stage investment has fallen in recent years as investors have become more cautious about the risks. They still have money to put to work. Businesses that generate cash and grow at a steady, if slower, pace look more attractive today than they did a year or two ago.
  3. Making money in the stock market has become harder. A rising market can boost almost everything. Making money through a downturn and the recovery that follows takes much more expertise.
Related Materials