Legal experts urge Germany to drop Alisher Usmanov tax probe

Published

Germany’s remaining criminal investigation into Alisher Usmanov began with an anonymous tip about a property. Four years on, three specialists in criminal tax law say investigators still lack sufficient grounds to prosecute the Uzbekistan-born billionaire.

Germany’s Die Welt newspaper has obtained a legal opinion from Karsten Fehn, Bernd Josef Fehn and Jan Ole Schmieding, according to Lars Petersen, an investigative team lead at Die Welt, Business Insider Deutschland and Politico Deutschland.

The three experts questioned the way the inquiry was started, how investigators determined Usmanov’s tax residency and how long it took to give access to the evidence to his lawyers.

The EU removed Usmanov from its sanctions list on 22 September. In 2022, the bloc had frozen his assets and imposed a travel ban, citing what it described as close ties to Russian president Vladimir Putin. Usmanov challenged the grounds for the sanctions. In October, Germany’s Federal Court of Justice cleared a procedural hurdle in his separate lawsuit against the EU Council.

German prosecutors had already closed a money laundering inquiry and a separate investigation into possible sanctions breaches. Usmanov agreed to pay €10 million as a condition of closing the sanctions case. The tax inquiry remains open, Die Welt reported.

An anonymous tip and a rejected search

The experts said the tip to Germany’s Federal Criminal Police Office concerned a possible sanctions breach and suggested a German property could be linked to Usmanov. The tip raised no tax allegation and omitted his name.

An investigating judge initially refused to authorise a search, citing insufficient grounds for suspicion. Investigators then turned to another local court.

The dispute over tax residence

Investigators believe Usmanov owned a house in Germany for more than a decade and failed to file tax returns. Estimates of what he allegedly owed ranged from millions to billions of euros, with no explanation in the files for the changes, the experts remarked.

Investigators made the case for German residence by using clues such as hotel accommodation, cars, staff and short-term leases. The experts noted that investigators also ruled out Usmanov’s Moscow address by using Google Street View and had ignored material that could have aided his case, including visas, witness statements, Russian tax records and German federal tax data on his residence.

Read more: Münchner Merkur reports villa tied to Usmanov on the market in Germany

Four years to review seized evidence

One foreign judicial authority rejected a German request for assistance as a «fishing expedition», the authors said. In another instance, they said investigators presented unverified allegations to a European authority as facts. The experts saw both requests as signs that investigators were still looking for grounds to support their suspicions.

Searches yielded about 1,000 binders and several terabytes of data. The preliminary review took four years, a delay the experts considered disproportionate. Defence lawyers initially had no access to the files, but they later gained limited access to them.

Safeguards against political interference

They could see more of the material after two years, although parts of the tax files remained out of reach. Some seized data became available to the defence only more than three years after the searches took place.

Read more: Usmanov does not own Dilbar yacht, German court rules

The authors cited a newly opened line of inquiry into an event more than a decade old. This new line of inquiry relied on an assumption about Usmanov’s residence for a year, which investigators themselves disagreed with. The experts recommended closing the case and strengthening safeguards against political interference, stating that they found no evidence of such interference in this investigation.

Read also